I’ve seen a lot of recipes for oreos over the past year or so, as it has become increasingly trendy to make classic American treats at home (twinkies, hostess cupcakes, oreos, ketchup, etc). I usually pass them by, thinking that while homemade hostess cupcakes are great, nothing could be better than storebought, mass-produced Oreos. There’s something about the balance that storebought Oreos achieve that remains elusive in so many homemade recipes, and from the recipe below, I think it comes down to texture and salt. The recipe in this post comes as close as possible to replicating the salty cookie, sweet filling balance, and the chocolate cookie has a sandy texture that is similar to that of storebought Oreos. This being a recipe developed by Thomas Keller, I found in my tests that there was no need to fiddle with its proportions. I have, however, rewritten the instructions in a lot more detail, to provide more guidance on how the dough behaves. You can make these cookies with a hand mixer or stand mixer, but it is much, much easier in a food processor. Making them with a hand mixer will take you about 20 minutes of mixing to get the dough to wet crumbs, at which point it can be mooshed into a disk of dough.
When I included these cookies in this year’s xmas cookie boxes, I was looking for a dark chocolate wafer. Typically I would use my go-to Alice Medrich chocolate wafer recipe that I use for icebox cakes, but I wanted something here that looked a bit fancier, so I used just the cookie part of the TKO recipe, without the filling. I had scads of leftover cookies, so I decided to test the filling – my first impression was that the white chocolate ganache would overwhelm the chocolate cookie. I also didn’t know how much moisture the cookie would absorb from the ganache, and I generally pick cookies for the boxes that I know will go stale very slowly. I can now happily tell you – and I believe my co-workers would agree – that the filling is definitely a good idea, and that the cookies more than stand up to it for at least a week. Further than a week, I don’t know, because the cookies were long gone by then. The cookies do absorb a little bit of moisture from the filling – just enough so that the cookie sticks together and doesn’t fall apart when you bite into it – but they remain crisp overall. (more…)